Customs affairs lawyer

Appeal of decisions, actions and inaction of customs authorities

Comprehensive legal protection of foreign-trade operators and individuals against unlawful decisions and actions of customs: appealing refusal cards in customs clearance, decisions on the adjustment of the customs value (RKMV), changes in goods classification (KTTU) and inaction of customs authorities in pre-trial and judicial proceedings.

Appeal of customs decisions

01 / Subject of appeal

Subject of appeal: from refusal of clearance to unlawful customs actions

Ukrainian legislation grants persons the right to appeal decisions, actions or inaction of customs authorities if they violate their rights, freedoms or legitimate interests. The main objects of appeal include:

Refusal cards in customs clearance

Refusal to accept a customs declaration or to clear goods, unlawful delay of the procedure or unjustified demands for additional documents.

Decisions on the adjustment of the customs value (RKMV)

Adjustment of the declared customs value of goods and non-recognition of the contract price (Art. 55 of the CCU), which may lead to additional duty and VAT charges.

Decisions on goods classification (KTTU)

A forced change of the UKT ZED code, which may lead to additional customs payments.

Decisions on the country of origin of goods

Cancellation of preferential duty rates or the application of anti-dumping measures.

Inaction of customs authorities

Failure to return a deposit, delay in unblocking cargo or ignoring a taxpayer’s applications.

02 / Methods and procedures of appeal

Procedure and time limits: pre-trial and judicial appeal

Protection of rights is carried out in pre-trial (administrative) and judicial proceedings. The choice of procedure depends on the type of act being appealed: for decisions in customs violation cases (PMP) the special procedure of Chapter 49 of the Customs Code (Arts. 529–533) applies, while appealing RKMV, KTTU, refusal cards and inaction is carried out under the general rules of administrative court procedure (CASU).

Pre-trial (administrative) appeal

Filing a complaint with a higher customs authority. For decisions in customs violation cases, the time limit and procedure are determined by Art. 529 of the CCU and the CUAO. Filing an administrative complaint, as a rule, does not preclude further recourse to the court.

Judicial appeal under the CASU

Filing an administrative claim with a district administrative court. The general time limit for applying to the court is six months from the day the person became aware of the violation of their rights; in certain categories of cases the time limit may differ.

These grounds apply specifically to decisions in customs violation cases and are not a universal way to appeal any customs act. The existence of a ground does not guarantee cancellation — the court evaluates all the circumstances of the case together:

01

Absence of the event or elements of an offence

Absence in the person’s actions of the event and/or the elements of a violation of customs rules.

02

Lack of objectivity or incompleteness

Lack of objectivity or incompleteness of the proceedings or bias in their consideration by the customs authority.

03

Inconsistency of conclusions

Inconsistency of the conclusions set out in the decision with the actual circumstances of the case.

04

Procedural violations

Issuance of the decision by an unauthorized person, unjustified non-admission to participation in the consideration of the case of the person held liable or their representative, as well as other limitation of the rights of participants in the proceedings.

05

Incorrect qualification

Incorrect or incomplete qualification of the committed offence.

06

Sanction not provided for

Imposition of a sanction not provided for by the Customs Code, or in an amount that does not correspond to the sanction of the article of the Code under which the offence is qualified.

03 / Step-by-step defense algorithm

Stages of legal support for the appeal procedure

The defense process is built on a procedural framework; the actual sequence and the availability of specific actions depend on the circumstances of the case:

  1. 01
    Legal analysis and recording of violations

    Verification of the appealed decision or refusal card for compliance with the requirements of the CCU, identification of formal and substantive defects.

  2. 02
    Building the evidence base

    Formation of a package of primary documents: invoices, price lists, transport waybills (CMR/BL), export declarations of the country of dispatch, technical descriptions.

  3. 03
    Drafting and filing the complaint/claim

    Drafting a reasoned complaint or claim with references to current legislation and up-to-date court practice.

  4. 04
    Judicial representation

    Conducting the proceedings in court, filing motions, including for interim relief, in order to protect the client’s interests.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Does filing a complaint suspend the effect of the appealed customs decision?

As a general rule, filing an administrative complaint does not suspend the effect of the appealed decision. For decisions in customs violation cases, Art. 533 of the CCU provides for the suspension of the execution of the decision until the complaint is considered. In other cases, suspension of the decision’s effect is possible only by a court decision upon a party’s application, which the court may grant where grounds exist.

What are the chances of cancelling a customs clearance refusal card?

The prospects of appeal depend on the circumstances of the specific case: whether the customs authority justified the refusal with reference to legal norms, whether it demanded documents not provided for by the CCU, and on the available evidence. Prospects can be assessed only after reviewing the materials.

How long does the appeal procedure take?

Time limits depend on the chosen procedure and the category of the case. An administrative appeal is considered by a higher customs authority within the time limits set by law; judicial proceedings under the CASU take depending on the court’s workload and the complexity of the case. Exact time limits are assessed after analyzing the situation.

Can damages for cargo downtime be recovered when appealing a customs decision?

Damage caused by unlawful decisions, actions or inaction of state authorities may be compensated in court proceedings provided there is evidence of the unlawfulness of the act, the amount of damage and a causal link between them. This requires proving all the circumstances and is not guaranteed automatically.

The information on the website is of a general introductory nature and does not replace individual legal advice. Assessing the prospects of appealing customs decisions depends on the available evidence, compliance with the time limits for filing and the circumstances of the specific case.

04 / CONTACT

Consultation with a lawyer.

Tell us about your question. We will review your enquiry and respond using the contact details you provide.

OUR LOCATION

Odesa, Ukraine

CONSULTATION FORMAT

Online or in person by arrangement

CONTACT THE LAWYER

Through the website enquiry form

Confidential. No obligation. Focused on you.