Political asylum and refugee status

Persecution, Threats and Harassment for Asylum

Professional legal analysis: a breakdown of the key criteria, evidentiary standards and the legal nature of persecution in international immigration law.

Discuss your case

01 / WHAT PERSECUTION IS

What is «persecution» from the perspective of international law?

In the context of the 1951 Geneva Convention and its 1967 Protocol, the very concept of asylum is inseparable from persecution. The law does not grant protection to everyone who faces hardship or discomfort in their country. For a case to succeed before an immigration authority or court, the documented facts must meet clear legal standards.

KEY PRINCIPLES

Systematic and repeated nature

Persecution is generally systematic — or a single incident of catastrophic severity (an attempt on life, torture).

Targeted character

The acts are directed specifically at you or at the group to which you belong, rather than being random.

Causal link (Nexus)

The persecution is connected to one of the five protected grounds: race, religion, nationality, social group or political opinion.

State involvement or acquiescence

The authorities are themselves the source of the threat, or they refuse or are unable to protect the victim.

02 / MAIN CRITERIA

Main criteria for assessing persecution, threats and harassment

Intensity and severity (Severe Harm)

Persecution must reach the level of serious harm that threatens life, liberty or basic conditions of existence.

  • Threat to life or liberty: attempts, torture, unlawful deprivation of liberty, cruel treatment.
  • Politically motivated persecution: fabricated cases, harsh sentences for peaceful protest or human-rights work.
  • Serious economic harassment: dismissal, professional ban, confiscation of property, deprivation of livelihood.
  • Physical violence: beatings, hate-crime attacks, sexual violence tolerated by the police.

Well-founded fear (Well-Founded Fear)

Proving a real, not hypothetical, risk of escalation. A reasonable person in your situation would feel under threat.

Impossibility of internal relocation

Proving that moving to another region of the country is impossible due to the nationwide reach of the persecutors or a high level of danger.

Inability or unwillingness of the state to protect

Police inaction, unjust court rulings, involvement of officials in pressure exerted on the applicant.

03 / WHAT IS NOT ACCEPTED

What kinds of threats and harassment are NOT accepted by immigration authorities?

General high crime rate or poverty

War, inflation or poverty in themselves are not grounds for asylum if there is no targeted persecution on a protected ground.

Domestic conflicts

Disputes with neighbours, family or commercial disputes without a political or discriminatory context.

Random acts of rudeness

Isolated street insults that do not threaten life and have no systematic character.

04 / THE LAWYER’S ROLE

The role of legal support in proving persecution

  1. 01
    Legal qualification of the facts

    We analyse the circumstances and determine whether they meet the legal standards of persecution.

  2. 02
    Gathering and legalizing evidence

    We help collect certificates, medical reports, witness statements and other supporting documents.

  3. 03
    Drafting a legally sound Affidavit

    We prepare a Personal Statement set out in language understandable to the immigration authority.

  4. 04
    Full legal support

    We represent your interests before the immigration authority or court until a decision is made by the competent body.

05 / FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ)

  1. 01
    What if the threats were only verbal, with no written evidence?

    Verbal threats also carry legal weight if they were systematic. In such cases the evidence base is built on witness testimony, a detailed Affidavit, psychological assessments and reports from international organisations on the situation in the region.

  2. 02
    Can I obtain asylum if the persecution came not from the authorities but from private individuals?

    This is possible, provided you can prove the state’s inability or unwillingness (police, courts) to protect you from these individuals — for example, that appeals to the police were ignored.

  3. 03
    Is dismissal from work considered persecution for asylum purposes?

    Dismissal may be considered persecution if it was motivated by discrimination (politics, religion, orientation) and deprived you of basic means of subsistence (Severe Economic Deprivation). The final assessment is made by the competent authority.

  4. 04
    How many incidents or attacks must be documented to establish «systematic» persecution?

    There is no fixed numerical threshold. It may be a series of several lesser forms of harassment that together create intolerable conditions, or a single incident of catastrophic severity (for example, an attempt on life or torture).

The information on this website is of a general introductory nature and does not replace individual legal advice. The outcome of a case depends on the circumstances and the decisions of the competent authorities.

04 / CONTACT

Consultation with a lawyer.

Tell us about your question. We will review your enquiry and respond using the contact details you provide.

OUR LOCATION

Odesa, Ukraine

CONSULTATION FORMAT

Online or in person by arrangement

CONTACT THE LAWYER

Through the website enquiry form

Confidential. No obligation. Focused on you.