Temporary protection for Ukrainians

Restrictions on temporary protection in EU countries

A comprehensive legal analysis of the updated reforms of Directive 2001/55/EC and the national laws of EU member states: the “safe regions” concept, legal requirements for border crossing, the specific situation of men of military age, and protection against the cancellation of benefits or refusals of protection.

Assess the risks and get a consultation

01 / Transformation of Directive 2001/55/EC

A new legal reality for temporary protection in Europe

The Temporary Protection mechanism under Directive 2001/55/EC and Council Implementing Decision 2022/382 remains in force, but its application is no longer unconditional. Individual EU and EEA states have introduced national legal and administrative filters. It is important to distinguish temporary protection (a special status for mass arrivals) from the asylum procedure (Asylum) — these are different legal regimes with different grounds and consequences. The following is general information; applying it to a specific case requires individual analysis:

02 / Key legislative restrictions

Main categories of grounds for refusal or cancellation of status

The list below generalises the practices of individual states and is not a single pan-European rule. The specific grounds, consequences and availability of protection are determined by the national law of the host state and the circumstances of the case:

01

“Safe regions” concept (Safe Regions)

Individual states (including Norway, as well as certain German federal states and migration authorities in Czechia) apply a differentiated approach to persons whose last permanent place of residence was registered in regions of Ukraine far from active hostilities. This is national practice, not a rule of Directive 2001/55/EC itself. In such cases, instead of automatic temporary protection, a person may be offered the general Asylum procedure, where an individual threat must be proven. The availability and limits of this approach depend on the state and are not guaranteed.

02

Unlawful border crossing and immigration regime

Entering the EU outside official border crossing points, with forged documents or without border inspection may lead to checks by security authorities, including through the Schengen Information System (SIS). The existence of convictions, fines for border violations or overstays under the Schengen visa regime may be considered a ground for refusal under public policy or security exceptions (Public Policy Exception). Consequences depend on the state and circumstances.

03

Status of men of military age (18–60) and military registration

Directive 2001/55/EC itself does not require military service in another state for the grant of protection. However, Ukrainian martial-law legislation restricts the departure of men aged 18–60 and links the provision of consular services to the possession of updated military-registration documents. The absence of a valid Ukrainian passport complicates the renewal of national residence cards (Residence Cards / Fiktionsbescheinigung) in many countries. In some states (for example Germany), where obtaining a new Ukrainian passport is legally impossible, the issue of an alien’s passport (Reiseausweis für Ausländer) may be considered, but this requires justification and is not guaranteed.

04

Prohibition of repeated protection (Protection Shopping)

National legislation in a number of states (for example Lex Ukrajina in Czechia, the Act on Assistance to Ukrainian Citizens in Poland) restricts the repeated registration of temporary protection where a person has already been granted equivalent status in another EU/EEA state. Concealing the receipt of benefits or a residence permit in one country in order to move to another may lead to cancellation of registration and a demand to return the assistance provided. The rules and consequences differ by state.

03 / Socio-economic status

Cancellation of social support and new obligations

The conditions of social support are set by national law and are subject to change. The warning blocks below reflect the practices of individual states; the specific periods and amounts of assistance depend on the host state:

Condition of mandatory employability

Most EU states are gradually shortening the periods of basic social benefits (Bürgergeld in Germany, sosialhjelp in Norway, etc.). Refusal of offered work or language-integration courses may lead to a complete termination of financial support. The exact conditions depend on the state.

Limits on free housing

Free accommodation in municipal reception centres is limited to fixed periods (for example, around 90–150 days depending on the state and region), after which the person must rent housing independently or find employment. The periods differ by state and municipality.

Loss of status on prolonged absence

Leaving the state that granted temporary protection (including trips to Ukraine) for more than 30–60 days may lead to cancellation of status and financial assistance. The permitted length of absence is set by national law and is not uniform across the EU.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Can temporary protection be refused if a person is registered in western regions of Ukraine?

This is possible in individual states. Norway and some German federal states apply a regional approach and may refuse automatic temporary protection to residents of regions considered relatively safe, offering instead the general Asylum procedure requiring proof of an individual threat. This is national practice, not a pan-European rule; the outcome depends on the state and the circumstances of the case.

How does a trip to Ukraine affect the retention of temporary protection in the EU?

Short-term trips (usually up to 30 days) are often permitted for valid reasons, but the permitted length of absence is set by the host state. A prolonged stay in Ukraine may be classified as voluntary return and the cessation of a need for international protection, leading to the cancellation of benefits and the residence permit. The exact periods depend on national law.

What should men of military age do when their passport expires?

Without a valid travel document, renewing a residence permit in many EU countries is difficult. In some states (for example Germany), where obtaining a new Ukrainian passport is legally impossible, the issue of an alien’s passport (Reiseausweis für Ausländer) may be considered, but this requires legal justification and is not guaranteed. Availability depends on the state and circumstances.

Is it possible to change the country of temporary protection within the EU?

This is possible only through the official procedure of renouncing status in the first country (Abmeldung/Unregister) and obtaining the written consent of the new country. An unsanctioned change may lead to refusal under the rules restricting repeated protection (Protection Shopping). The rules and consequences differ by state.

The information on the website is of a general introductory nature and does not replace individual legal advice. The rules of temporary protection and national restrictions differ by EU/EEA state and are subject to change. The outcome of a case depends on the circumstances and the decisions of the competent authorities of the relevant state.

04 / CONTACT

Consultation with a lawyer.

Tell us about your question. We will review your enquiry and respond using the contact details you provide.

OUR LOCATION

Odesa, Ukraine

CONSULTATION FORMAT

Online or in person by arrangement

CONTACT THE LAWYER

Through the website enquiry form

Confidential. No obligation. Focused on you.