International criminal law

Defense in Extradition and Surrender Cases

Professional legal defense of foreign citizens and stateless persons in extradition (surrender) proceedings from Ukraine: challenging the actions of the Prosecutor General’s Office and related decisions, preventing extradition arrest, and substantiating risks of torture or political persecution in the requesting state.

Defense against extradition

01 / Legal nature of extradition and grounds for refusal

The extradition procedure and statutory bars to surrender

Extradition (surrender of a person) is a legal mechanism of international cooperation in criminal proceedings that involves transferring a person to a state seeking them for criminal prosecution or enforcement of a sentence (Art. 573 of the CPC of Ukraine).

Foreign citizens and stateless persons present on the territory of Ukraine are subject to extradition. At the same time, national legislation and international treaties of Ukraine establish strict procedural guarantees and bars to surrender, provided in particular by Art. 589 of the CPC of Ukraine and the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms.

01

Absolute bar to the surrender of Ukrainian citizens

The Constitution of Ukraine (Art. 25) and Art. 589 of the CPC of Ukraine strictly prohibit the surrender of a Ukrainian citizen to a foreign state. Where relevant international legal assistance treaties exist, criminal prosecution of a Ukrainian citizen for an act committed abroad may be carried out by Ukrainian law enforcement authorities under Art. 8 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine.

02

Extradition of foreigners and stateless persons: protection guarantees

Foreign citizens and stateless persons present on the territory of Ukraine are subject to the extradition procedure; however, their surrender is not permitted where grounds exist under Art. 589 of the CPC of Ukraine and Ukraine’s international obligations under the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms.

03

Risk of torture, ill-treatment or political persecution

Surrender is not permitted where there are reasonable grounds to believe that the criminal prosecution bears signs of political, racial, religious or other discriminatory pressure, or that after surrender the person would face torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, or a violation of the right to a fair trial in the requesting state (Art. 3 and Art. 6 ECHR, Art. 589 of the CPC).

04

Grant of refugee status or complementary protection in Ukraine

Surrender is not permitted where the person has been granted refugee status or complementary protection in Ukraine with respect to the requesting state. Where the person has filed an application for such protection, the surrender procedure is suspended until a final decision is taken by the competent migration and judicial authorities (Art. 589 of the CPC).

05

Expiration of statutes of limitation and double criminality

Surrender is not permitted where, under the law of Ukraine or the requesting state, the time limits for criminal prosecution or enforcement of the sentence have expired, or where the act giving rise to the request is not recognized as a criminal offense under Ukrainian law — the principle of double criminality (Art. 589 of the CPC).

02 / Preventive measures in extradition

Temporary detention and extradition arrest

A person subject to an extradition request may be subject to preventive measures involving restriction of liberty. Each has procedural time limits and may be appealed:

01

Temporary detention (up to 40 days)

Applied by an investigating judge on a prosecutor’s motion to hold a person until an official extradition request is received from a foreign state (Art. 583 of the CPC).

02

Custody (extradition arrest)

Applied after the extradition request materials arrive, for the duration of the extradition check. The total period of custody during surrender may not exceed 12 months (Art. 584 of the CPC).

03

Alternative preventive measures

The lawyer’s task is to challenge the choice of custody and to seek its replacement with a less restrictive preventive measure (bail, personal undertaking, etc.) where permitted by law, taking into account the circumstances of the case.

03 / Stages of legal defense against surrender

Step-by-step algorithm of legal support

Defense in extradition cases requires systematic procedural work. An indicative sequence of actions; the actual sequence and content depend on the circumstances of the specific case:

  1. 01
    Prompt intervention upon detention

    The lawyer’s participation during the investigating judge’s hearing of a motion for temporary detention or custody, verification of the legality of detention, and recording of procedural violations.

  2. 02
    Gathering materials for the extradition check

    Submitting to the prosecution (Prosecutor General’s Office) evidence of grounds for refusing surrender under Art. 589 of the CPC, including risks of persecution and human rights violations.

  3. 03
    Using international mechanisms

    Applying to the State Migration Service to file an application for refugee status or complementary protection, and petitioning the European Court of Human Rights to apply Rule 39 of the Rules of Court.

  4. 04
    Judicial appeal of the surrender decision

    Appealing surrender and preventive-measure decisions before the investigating judge and the appellate court, preparing procedural documents and representing the person’s interests.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Can a Ukrainian citizen be extradited abroad?

No. The Constitution of Ukraine (Art. 25) prohibits the surrender of a Ukrainian citizen to a foreign state. Where grounds exist, criminal prosecution may be carried out by Ukrainian law enforcement authorities on the basis of international legal assistance treaties.

How long can an extradition arrest last in Ukraine?

The total period of custody during the extradition check and the consideration of appeals may not exceed 12 months (Art. 584 of the CPC). The period of temporary detention before a request arrives is limited to 40 days.

How does an application for protection (refugee status) affect the extradition procedure?

Filing an application for refugee status or complementary protection in Ukraine suspends the consideration of the surrender question until a final decision is taken by the competent authorities and courts. The final outcome depends on the result of that application.

What is Rule 39 of the Rules of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)?

It is an interim measure of the ECtHR by which a state may be indicated to refrain from surrendering a person where there is a real risk of torture or ill-treatment in the requesting state (Art. 3 ECHR). The application of Rule 39 does not guarantee a final outcome and is considered by the court individually.

The information on the website is of a general introductory nature and does not replace individual legal advice. The outcomes of challenging extradition decisions depend on the available evidence, international guarantees, and the procedural decisions of the competent authorities and courts.

04 / CONTACT

Consultation with a lawyer.

Tell us about your question. We will review your enquiry and respond using the contact details you provide.

OUR LOCATION

Odesa, Ukraine

CONSULTATION FORMAT

Online or in person by arrangement

CONTACT THE LAWYER

Through the website enquiry form

Confidential. No obligation. Focused on you.