International criminal law

International Legal Assistance in Criminal Cases

Professional legal defense of individuals and legal entities during the execution of international requests (letters rogatory) in criminal proceedings: support during interrogations, searches, temporary access to things and documents, verification of the lawfulness of foreign procedural acts and challenging unlawful actions of the authorized authorities of Ukraine.

Legal assistance

01 / Legal nature and types of international legal assistance

Procedural forms of international cooperation in criminal matters

International legal assistance is a procedure regulated by Chapter IX of the CPC of Ukraine and the relevant international treaties under which the competent authorities of one state carry out procedural actions at the request (petition) of another state. The list of actions and the conditions for their execution depend on the applicable treaty and the circumstances of the specific case:

01

Service of procedural documents

Official service of notices of suspicion, summonses, indictments and court decisions of foreign authorities in the manner determined by the international treaty and the CPC of Ukraine.

02

Interrogation of witnesses, victims, suspects and experts

Interrogations conducted by authorized Ukrainian investigators or prosecutors, including by videoconference, subject to the permission of the Ukrainian central authority for the participation of foreign representatives.

03

Searches, inspections and seizures

Investigative actions carried out on the territory of Ukraine in execution of a foreign state’s request, generally under a ruling of the investigating judge and in compliance with the requirements of the CPC of Ukraine.

04

Temporary access to things and documents

Obtaining banking, commercial and other documents constituting a secret under international requests in the manner provided by the CPC of Ukraine and the relevant treaty.

05

Temporary transfer of persons

Transfer of persons held in custody or serving a sentence to participate in procedural actions abroad — possible only where the relevant international treaty applies and with the person’s consent.

02 / The role of counsel in executing international requests

Protection of rights and countering procedural violations

Engagement of counsel facilitates compliance with the procedural rights of the person during interaction with the competent authorities (the Prosecutor General’s Office, the Ministry of Justice, the State Bureau of Investigation, the Bureau of Economic Security). The main directions of counsel’s participation:

01

Control of the lawfulness of the foreign request

Analysis of the request for compliance with the requirements of Art. 552 of the CPC of Ukraine, the principle of double criminality and the sovereignty of Ukraine. The findings are advisory in nature and do not determine the final decision of the competent authorities.

02

Defense during investigative actions

Participation of counsel in interrogations, searches and inspections to facilitate observance of the right not to testify against oneself and one’s family members (Art. 63 of the Constitution of Ukraine) and other procedural guarantees.

03

Appeal of investigating judges’ rulings

Filing appellate complaints against decisions authorizing a search or temporary access issued in the course of executing an international request, in the manner provided by the CPC of Ukraine.

04

Legalization and admissibility of evidence

Assessment of materials obtained abroad for their admissibility and relevance in court proceedings, taking into account the requirements of apostille or consular legalization and a notarized translation. The final decision on admissibility is made by the court.

03 / Step-by-step algorithm of legal support

Stages of legal support

Defense in international legal assistance procedures follows a procedural framework. An indicative sequence of actions; the actual sequence and content depend on the circumstances of the specific case:

  1. 01
    Analysis of the incoming request

    Examining the grounds for serving documents or conducting investigative actions at the request of the Ukrainian central authority (the PGO or the Ministry of Justice) and verifying the applicability of the relevant international treaty.

  2. 02
    Preparation of the defense position

    Forming legal arguments, preparing written objections and, where necessary, agreeing on the line of conduct before procedural actions are carried out.

  3. 03
    Procedural support

    Participation of counsel in the court hearing of the investigating judge and directly during the execution of investigative actions on the territory of Ukraine, within the limits permitted by law.

  4. 04
    Appeal and recording of violations

    Challenging unlawful actions or decisions of the competent authorities in the manner prescribed by law, where the conduct of investigative actions violates international obligations or human rights. The outcome depends on the procedural decisions of the competent authorities and the court.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Is it mandatory to appear in response to a summons sent from a foreign state?

Service of a foreign summons must take place in the manner determined by the international treaty and the CPC of Ukraine. Refusal to appear in response to a foreign summons does not always entail compulsory bring-in, however the consequences depend on the specific treaty and require detailed analysis by counsel.

Do foreign investigators have the right to personally conduct an interrogation or a search in Ukraine?

No. Foreign officials may be present during investigative actions only with the permission of the Ukrainian central authority, however the procedural actions themselves are carried out exclusively by Ukrainian investigators or prosecutors in accordance with the CPC of Ukraine.

Can one refuse to testify at the request of a foreign state?

A person has the right to use the procedural guarantees and immunities provided by the law of Ukraine (in particular Art. 63 of the Constitution of Ukraine) and, where applicable, the law of the requesting state. The scope of such guarantees depends on the specific international treaty.

How can the admissibility of evidence obtained under an international letter rogatory be verified?

Evidence must be obtained in compliance with the procedure provided by the relevant international treaty and the CPC of Ukraine. A violation of the procedure for filing or executing a request may be a ground for a motion to have the evidence declared inadmissible; the final decision is made by the court.

The information on the website is of a general introductory nature and does not replace individual legal advice. The assessment of the admissibility of evidence and procedural actions within the framework of international assistance depends on the specific international treaty and court decisions.

04 / CONTACT

Consultation with a lawyer.

Tell us about your question. We will review your enquiry and respond using the contact details you provide.

OUR LOCATION

Odesa, Ukraine

CONSULTATION FORMAT

Online or in person by arrangement

CONTACT THE LAWYER

Through the website enquiry form

Confidential. No obligation. Focused on you.